R: I’d like you to give evidence or sources when you talk about it.
Tarky: What do you mean? Commentators on TV shows say whatever they want.
R: Those are experts of some kind, aren’t they? I’d like you to ensure their expertise.
Tarky: That’s a natural science argument, so I don’t think it’s something that is generally required or accepted.
R: Does that mean you think so?
Tarky: The argument is refined with evidence. The argument is refined by criticism. I think this is a special method of argumentation in the natural sciences, which we developed in our graduate school days. It’s not the best way to appeal to the masses.
[Read More]